Atlanta prosecutors hope to persuade jury to second-guess officer who shot Brooks

(Reuters) – Prosecutors searching for to convict Atlanta police officer Garrett Rolfe for homicide within the taking pictures loss of life of Rayshard Brooks should attempt to persuade jurors to do one thing they hardly ever do – second guess split-second police choices.

FILE PHOTO: Protesters rally in opposition to racial inequality and the police taking pictures loss of life of Rayshard Brooks, in Atlanta, Georgia, U.S. June 13, 2020. REUTERS/Elijah Nouvelage/File Photo

On Wednesday, Fulton County District Attorney Paul Howard introduced 11 fees in opposition to Rolfe, with essentially the most critical being felony homicide which carries the loss of life penalty.

Atlanta’s mayor fired Rolfe after Friday’s taking pictures. Civil rights teams had been fast to sentence the deadly strategies. Protests broke out within the metropolis because the taking pictures fueled fashionable outrage that adopted the May 25 loss of life of one other unarmed black man, George Floyd, as an officer knelt on his neck throughout his arrest in Minnesota.

Video of the taking pictures that went viral will doubtless assist the prosecution, and Howard famous that Devin Brosnan, Rolfe’s accomplice, agreed to turn into the uncommon police officer who will testify in opposition to a colleague.

Prosecutors will stress that the officer shot Brooks within the again as he fled, and demand that the suspect posed no risk. Defense attorneys will doubtless observe that Brooks took the officer’s Taser, or stun gun, and brandished it earlier than he fled.

Steve Gaynor, president of the Fraternal Order of Police in Cobbs County in Georgia, insisted that Rolfe’s actions had been justified underneath U.S. Supreme Court steerage.

“Look at case law. The officer is well within his right to use deadly force,” stated Gaynor.

Laws governing police use of power differ by state, however the Supreme Court has stated lethal power can be utilized if an officer fairly believes the suspect poses an instantaneous risk of great damage to the officer or others.

Georgia permits use of lethal power to apprehend a suspect when officers have possible trigger to consider the suspect dedicated a criminal offense involving infliction or threatened infliction of great hurt, which Gaynor stated Brooks had completed.

He stated Brooks dedicated assault on the officers, a theft when he seized the stun gun and aggravated assault when fired the stun gun on the officers.

Howard, the district lawyer, stated Brooks posed no risk as he was fleeing as a result of he had discharged the out there pictures from the stun gun. Gaynor disagreed.

“It’s still a weapon, maybe not a deadly weapons but it is a weapon. The public is still in jeopardy at that point,” stated Gaynor.

Rolfe’s protection lawyer might additionally argue that he adopted police coaching protocols. Jack Ryan, who trains legislation enforcement nationwide, stated some police departments train officers to think about using lethal power if a suspect has gained management of an officer’s stun gun. However, that’s much less of a risk when there are a number of officers current.

The Atlanta police division didn’t reply to a request for touch upon its coaching.

Ultimately, like most circumstances in opposition to police, authorized consultants stated it might come down as to whether a jury is prepared to defer to an officer’s model of occasions.

Jonathan Rapping, president of the general public defender group Gideon’s Promise in Atlanta, stated white jurors in such circumstances usually are likely to exaggerate threats posed by minority suspects.

FILE PHOTO: Protesters block a freeway throughout a rally in opposition to racial inequality and the police taking pictures loss of life of Rayshard Brooks, in Atlanta, Georgia, U.S. June 13, 2020. REUTERS/Elijah Nouvelage/File Photo

“We’re reluctant to second-guess police,” stated Rapping, who’s a professor at John Marshall Law School.

For that cause, having testimony from Rolfe’s accomplice Brosnan might be key for prosecutors.

Sam Starks, an Atlanta felony protection lawyer, stated acquiring the cooperation of the opposite officer was a shock and “makes it harder for Rolfe.”

Reporting by Tom Hals in Wilmington, Delaware; Editing by Noeleen Walder and David Gregorio


What do you think?