Factbox: What’s the difference between three U.S. plans for police reform

WASHINGTON (Reuters) – President Donald Trump has signed an government order to deal with police misconduct following the killing of an African American man, George Floyd, in police custody.

FILE PHOTO – A participant raises a fist towards cops throughout an All Black Lives Matter march, organized by Black LGBTQ+ leaders, within the aftermath of the loss of life in Minneapolis police custody of George Floyd, in Hollywood, Los Angeles, California, U.S., June 14, 2020. REUTERS/Ringo Chiu

Democrats within the U.S. House of Representatives and Republicans within the Senate are additionally advancing separate payments to deal with the problem.

Following is a abstract of the three approaches:


Democrats – Reduce “qualified immunity” protections that defend police from civil misconduct lawsuits.

Republicans – No provision.

Trump – No provision.


Democrats – Designate chokeholds as lethal pressure that can be utilized solely when essential to guard life, and make pointless use a violation of U.S. civil rights legislation; withhold federal grant cash from police departments that don’t ban chokeholds.

Republicans – Withhold federal funds from police businesses that don’t prohibit chokeholds, besides when lethal pressure is allowed; instruct the U.S. Attorney General to develop a coverage to ban chokeholds by federal legislation enforcement.

Trump – Order the Attorney General to certify unbiased our bodies to substantiate that legislation enforcement businesses prohibit the usage of chokeholds, besides the place lethal pressure is allowed.


Democrats – Require lethal pressure for use solely as a final resort; require police businesses to report use-of-force knowledge.

Republicans – Require native governments to report deaths or accidents brought on by police; instruct the Justice Department to develop coaching in options to the usage of pressure.

Trump – Set up unbiased our bodies to make sure that use-of-force insurance policies are authorized; create a federal database to file situations of extreme use of pressure.


Democrats – Ban no-knock warrants in federal drug investigations; withhold grant cash from police businesses that use no-knock warrants.

Republicans – Require police businesses to report use of no-knock warrants.

Trump – No provision.


Democrats – Designate lynching as a federal hate crime.

Republicans – Designate lynching as a federal hate crime.

Trump – No provision.


Democrats – Eliminate federal practices that contain racial and non secular profiling; require police businesses to get rid of profiling as a way to get federal support; enable lawsuits by victims of profiling.

Republicans – No provision.

Trump – No provision.


Democrats – Require federal legislation enforcement to make use of physique cameras; grant cash for native businesses that use physique cameras.

Republicans – Make federal funds accessible to police businesses that require physique cameras.

Trump – No provision.


Democrats – No provision.

Republicans – Study packages to enhance police engagement on psychological well being, homelessness and dependancy.

Trump – Enable social employees to crew up with police to take care of these affected by psychological sickness, homelessness and dependancy; arrange coaching for police.

Reporting by David Morgan; Editing by Andy Sullivan and Sonya Hepinstall


What do you think?